A “Survivor 50” carrot is dangled.

Survivor 49 recap: Jeff Probst asks for a big move… and gets it

A "Survivor 50" carrot is dangled.

By Dalton Ross

Dalton Ross is a writer and editor with over 25 years experience covering TV and the entertainment industry. *Survivor* is kind of his thing.

EW's editorial guidelines

November 5, 2025 9:30 p.m. ET

Jeff Probst, Sophie Segreti, Jawann Pitts, Steven Ramm, and Alex Moore on 'Survivor 49'.

*“Just so you know, there are spots on *Survivor 50* still up for grabs. You want to be on *Survivor 50*, it happens here. This is where you make your career, or somebody makes their career off your back.”*

That was Hostmaster General Jeff Probst to the *Survivor 49* cast at this week’s challenge, essentially begging the players to start shaking things up more to give them better television after a super snoozy pre-merge portion of the season. The content of what Jeff was saying is not surprising in the least. In fact, this is just the type of thing he and producers tell the contestants right before filming begins in their pre-game Ponderosa pep talk as they try to inspire contestants to go all out. There is usually some form of “If you want to get invited back to play again, you have to play hard and play fast and play big” chat that takes place.

But to say it halfway through the game, and then include it on air and have it become a storyline is pretty notable. It’s notable in its subtle acknowledgment that playing it safe with votes was not creating any *Survivor* legends so far on season 49. It’s also kind of fascinating to see Probst dangling the carrot of a future season right in front of the players. That has to be the first time the franchise has openly acknowledged a future season on air during a current one.

I don’t have any issue with that — and actually *welcome* it if it leads to more aggressive gameplay — but because we’ve never seen it before, it did feel a little weird. Well, I’ll tell you one person who needs no reminders to be aggressive… Savannah! First off, she’s out giving chickens names before chopping their heads off. (My sources indicate Teriyaki was on the receiving end of that machete to the neck. The fate of both Kentucky Fried and General Tso remain unclear.) By the way, did you notice how Alex murdering a chicken was portrayed as a triumph of the human spirit while Savannah doing the same thing a few days later made her seem like a straight up serial killer? Same act. Very different editorial presentations.

Savannah Louie on 'Survivor 49'.

Robert Voets/CBS

But Savannah has an appetite — see what I did there? — for the aggressiveness Probst wants to see in other ways as well. She’s diving for keys that are part of someone else’s advantage. She’s then intentionally hovering over said someone else and acting like a self-described “psycho” by staring past their eyes and directly into their soul. “There’s a gleam in her eyes that’s a little evil,” noted MC.

That scene was so incredibly awkward… and wonderful. Why was MC even telling her what she was doing in looking for a key? And why was MC then telling Savannah she could *help* her look? And why was Savannah hovering over MC and the keys the same way my parents used to hover over me and make me empty my pockets when they suspected I might be carrying nefarious items on my person?

Even though the official *Survivor 49* pre-merge emoji might be a big fat yawn (or, perhaps a chicken screaming for mercy), there are signs that Probst did not even need to give his pre-challenge pep talk. Obviously, there’s Savannah… who may or may not be staring creepily into MC’s living room window as we speak. But there were also indications before that verbal kick in the pants that things were about to turn a bit topsy-turvy.

'Survivor 49' star Sage says hug denial was about 'self-respect, boundaries, honesty' (exclusive)

'Survivor 49' star Shannon Fairweather reacts to 'heartbreaking' Sage hug denial

Sage and Jawan took the first legitimate shot of the season last week in flipping on Shannon (who tried to flip on both Sage and Jawan at various points), so once all the Ulis met back up, it was pretty inevitable that we would get some more tribe-on-tribe crime. Is the back half of the season “bananas” as Probst has said because of that *Survivor 50* carrot he just dangled, or, like *Caramoan*, which also had a brutal pre-merge run before kicking it into gear in the second half, was the drama en route anyway?

We’ll never know, but Probst wasn’t taking any chances, doubling down at Tribal Council by telling the cast, “The merge really is where you forge a career. If you’re going to be a great player, it happens now. It doesn’t happen pre-merge.” Savannah even admitted during Tribal that all the *Survivor 50* had been working and swirling in her head. Now we’ll see if losing one of her own in Nate inspires even crazier gameplay. The host and the audience certainly hope so.

Okay, let’s go recap the rest of *Survivor 49,* episode 7 before Savannah grabs my keyboard and does it herself.

Michelle "MC" Chukwujekwu, Savannah Louie, Kristina Mills, Sophi Balerdi, Nate Moore, and Alex Moore on 'Survivor 49'.

The key to the merge

I cannot tell you how much respect I would have had for the Kele 3.0 tribe if they had just never come down to the beach to greet their newly merged tribe mates. It could have even been better than that. They could have each pretended they were doing chores, like working on their shelter, and barely acknowledged the arriving parties when they walked into camp — maybe just, like, a little nod along with a casual “Sup?” Of course, you can’t do that on *Survivor*. But I still wish they would have done that on *Survivor*.

Any new-era merge — and yes, they finally relented and called it a merge after pretending for a few seasons that it was not a merge even though it had all the elements of a merge and I am now going to stop typing the word *merge* — is usually accompanied by some sort of mad dash though the jungle, and this season that dash was for keys.

One of the hidden keys — and I use the word *hidden* loosely – would open a chest with an advantage. For a second there, I thought Jawan was going to make like my man Bruce Perreault and just kinda saunter in slow motion up into the woody thicket while others raced to find keys, but it turns out he had to put his shoes on. Why he did not put his shoes on *the second* that boat appeared knowing *Survivor* history is beyond me. You snooze, you lose!

It should be noted that often there is a beat that gets edited out before the search where players slip on their shoes or whatever before they all race up, but apparently this group was already anticipating Probst’s *play-harder-if-you-want-to-get-on-50* speech so just went for it and left Jawan in the dust to come up with more horror movie metaphors.

Congrats to Sage for finding the key. I mean, so much of this search was dumb luck and which key happened to open the chest, but the therapist is on a roll after flipping the script and taking out Shannon. (By the way, if you’re interested in reading something much more entertaining and insightful than this piece of nonsense, check out my exclusive mid-game interview with Sage, where she explains the reasoning behind her infamous hug denial and reveals lots of other intel and insight. Good stuff there!)

Jawann Pitts and Kristina Mills on 'Survivor 49'.

Robert Voets/CBS

Purple Sophie becomes Yellow Sophie becomes just plain Sophie

No need to “earn the merge” this season.  It’s already been earned! So said Probst to the final 11 while gifting them with goth, Sisters of Mercy-inspired black buffs. Because she found the key, Sage got a Fast Pass to the merge feast as well as the battle for individual immunity that preceded it. Everyone else was broken up into two teams and forced to dig out and push a massive boulder, collect a machete, chop a rope and then solve a puzzle that read “That is how you do it on *Survivor*.”

This was a super cool challenge construction. The only problem with it is that that the teams that had to cross over lanes with their giant boulders never actually ran into each other, but I still appreciate the effort from Kirhoffer and Co to gift me that potential physical chaos and mayhem. Of course, you all know me all too well and what I am about to say next — which is that as much fun as all that was, it was completely inconsequential. Because … say it with me… it’s ALL ABOUT THE PUZZLE!

This was proven once again when the blue team’s physical lead once again evaporated in the face of a puzzle. Credit goes to Sophi — who is now apparently Soph? — for figuring out the magic phrase for the yellow team’s puzzle solvers. They won the puzzle, so they won the challenge.

That meant Rizo, Nate, Steven, Sophie, and Sophi… sorry, I mean Soph!... joined a well-rested Sage in taking part in an individual challenge for immunity. The competition involved standing on a narrow beam while balancing a ball on a disc and moving feet and hands down the beam and pole at intervals. In the end, it came down to Steven versus Sophie, with the latter winning the first individual immunity of the season. Whether that makes up for getting a pretty invisible edit for the season so far only she can answer. But who knows, maybe this is the beginning of Yellow Sophie’s push for *Survivor 50!*

Sophie Segreti on 'Survivor 49'.

Robert Voets/CBS

Fiji’s Funniest Home Videos

I know I already got into the supes awkward interaction between MC and Savannah over MC’s Beware Advantage/immunity idol. It may be my favorite scene all season long just due to how weird both of them were at different junctions of the entire interaction. Here was MC having NO PLAN WHATSOEVER for if she was caught hunting for the key, and so having to clumsily act like she *wanted* help searching for thing she clearly did not want help searching for. And there was Savannah not only diving to the ground in an attempt to snatch MC’s key ring away from her, but also doing her best Andrea Boehlke babysitting impersonation (deep cut, look it up) as MC went from key to key. A+++ television.

But there was another moment that was even better. It only lasted approximately one second long and was in the midst of all the chatter about whom to put the Hina and Bottoms Up votes on (which we’ll get into in a minute). Steven was convinced the Uli votes would go on him. He was convinced of this fact because he said he was a much more physical threat than Kristina. As he uttered this, we were treated to a cutaway shot of Kristina sitting in a hammock that collapsed to the ground right on cue.

Allow me to say, this was maybe the most *Big Brother* moment in the history of *Survivor*, and that includes entire seasons with Hayden and Caleb. The house-set CBS reality competition franchise is famous (infamous?) for putting in the most embarrassing and hilarious cutaway scenes whenever a player is referenced. I still am haunted by the shot of Terrance (excuse me, DJ ShowTime) inspecting his man boobs during one particular BB cutaway during season 24.

I have the comedic appetite of a kindergartener, so anytime I see someone fall (without getting hurt) I am going to laugh. I am not proud of this fact, but that’s just the way it is. It’s low-hanging fruit, I know, but I’ve come to terms with it. So to see two people (Soph was also in said hammock) crash to the dirt for comedic juxtaposition was a chef’s kiss. The only thing that would have been better is if it was Steven that crashed to ground after saying what a physical threat he was. Sometimes the *Survivor* gods do not give with both hands.

The Hina, Kele, and Uli tribes merge on 'Survivor 49'.

Another one (of my picks) bites the dust

First off, let’s give props to the woman formerly known as Sophi. She once again had a prime opportunity to tell someone all about her Knowledge is Power advantage after Savannah informed her of MC’s idol, but Soph instead chose to zip the lips. I can’t tell you hard that is to do. Much harder than you think… which is why 95 percent of *Survivor* players who enter the game promising to never, ever reveal anything they find end up doing exactly that. They can’t help themselves. So good for her for having the willpower to keep that under wraps.

But I still can’t understand why Soph did not use her KIP later at Tribal Council. I get that it might have made her a target. And I get that they had two other options in Steven and Kristina to take out. But she knew where all the idols were! There’s a chance that would never happen again. Why risk letting that opportunity slip away, which it now may have? Plus, didn’t Soph listen to Probst earlier that day? THEY’RE CASTING SEASON 50! THIS IS A CHANCE TO PUNCH YOUR WONKA TICKET AND PLAY ALONGSIDE YOUR *SURVIVOR* CRUSH, CHRISTIAN HUBICKI! YOU COULD THEN LEAVE YOUR FIANCE AND RUN OFF AND HAVE LOTS OF NERD BABIES WITH SCRATCHED UP KNEES THAT COULD FORM THE BASIS OF BROCHACHOS 2.0: THE NEXT GENERATION! Oh well.

The most interesting development was happening on the other side as the members of original Hina and the newly formed Bottoms Up alliance (are they all alcoholics, or people with shady web browser histories, or did Steven convince them that he was actually on the bottom of Hina 1.0, which could not be any further from the truth?) all wanted someone different out. Jawan wanted Rizo to go because the R-I-Z-G-O-D was so comfortable that he was not going to use his idol, and then that idol would be put back into the game once Rizo was eliminated. Sage wanted Savannah out because she saw her as the dangerous ringleader of the entire Uli operation. Kristina wanted Nate out because it was the safest play, since Rizo has highly unlikely to play his idol on a guy who wore Rad Dad socks. (Although it would have been cinema if he had.)

Nate Moore on 'Survivor 49'.

***Want to be kept up with all things Survivor? Dig deep and sign up for 's free Survivor Weekly newsletter to have all the latest news, interviews, and commentary sent right to your inbox. ***

Who would it be? Off to Tribal we went to find out. The first thing that struck me about this Tribal was that Jawan clearly had yet to hit his weekly quota of horror movie references so had to go to that topic repeatedly. They’re not even references, now that I think about it. Like, he never cites specific movies, just the mere fact that horror movies exist and are scary… like *Survivor*. I keep waiting for him to represent old school B-level gems like *C.H.U.D.* (Cannibalistic Humanoid Underground Dwellers) and *The Stuff* (some sort of addictive yogurt type substance that consumes you from the inside and turns you into a zombie) but they never come! It was actually Sage who busted out the best horror comment of the week, noting that “Big groups are my version of a horror movie in general.” (Never have I felt more seen.)

Anyway, everyone voted, MC decided to use her idol even though the vote was not on her (whoops!), Rizo did not use his idol to save a fellow Uli when he could have (whoops!), and now Soph has to either find that new idol and find out who has it (possible whoops!). But forget all of them. Let’s talk about the person who *really* got hosed… ME! The elimination of Nate means yet another one of my preseason picks to win the game have — like the lady sitting next to me at the Patti Smith book reading and concert last night who required a booster seat — come up short.

I didn’t even retroactively jinx Nate this time, but made my prediction in Fiji the day before the game began after chatting with each of the cast members. Nate seemed smart, savvy, and level-headed enough to play strategically as opposed to emotionally. I liked his chances a lot and felt really good about my pick, thereby dooming Nate to a guaranteed loss. Poor guy never had a chance. Seriously, judging by my history of winner picks, Nate had less a chance of winning this season than Dr. Barry. Sorry about that, my man.

I plan to apologize to Nate in person when we chat on Thursday morning. In the meantime, make sure to check out my mid-game interview with Sage, as well as an exclusive deleted scene from the episode and the latest words of wisdom from Probst. And just a reminder that you can get all the latest *Survivor* intel and interviews sent right to you courtesy of our free *Survivor* newsletter. Go sign up now while I check in with Savannah to see how next week’s General Tso-infused scoop of the crispy is coming along.

Original Article on Source

Source: “EW Recaps”